Competitive separation refers to the process of distinguishing your brand from competitors by showcasing your unique selling points. In a crowded marketplace, it’s imperative to cultivate a distinctive brand identity to both attract and retain customers. In this post, we’ll explore what competitive separation is and how it benefits your brand safety in the world of display advertising.
What is competitive separation?
Competitive separation is the set of strategically selected measures advertisers adopt to distinguish themselves from their competition. It entails recognizing the unique attributes of a brand within an industry and leveraging them as primary marketing advantages. Emphasizing your distinctiveness enables you to shine amidst fierce competition, drawing in customers seeking something exceptional.
Why is competitive separation important?
In the contemporary digital era, brands encounter intense competition across all sectors. To thrive, it’s imperative to carve out a distinct identity amidst brands offering similar offerings. Highlighting your unique selling propositions allows you to cultivate a robust brand presence and establish yourself as the preferred option for customers seeking novelty.
Low competitive separation between brands in advertising can result in various consequences:
Brand Confusion: When multiple brands with similar products or services are featured closely together in ads, consumers may struggle to differentiate between them, leading to confusion and indecision in their purchasing process.
Reduced Brand Impact: With multiple competing brands appearing in close proximity, the individual impact of each brand’s message may be diluted, making it challenging for any single brand to stand out and capture the audience’s attention effectively.
Loss of Brand Identity: Without clear differentiation from competitors, brands may struggle to establish a unique identity and value proposition in the minds of consumers, ultimately weakening their long-term brand equity.
Price Competition: Low competitive separation can lead to heightened price competition among brands, as they vie for the attention of consumers within the same advertising space. This can erode profit margins and undermine the perceived value of products or services.
Brand Association: Brands may inadvertently become associated with competitors’ messaging or attributes when displayed in close proximity, potentially damaging their own brand image or reputation.
Competitive Separation in Display Advertising?
When it comes to display advertising, competitive separation can make all the difference. By highlighting what makes your brand unique, you can create ads that stand out from the rest and catch the attention of potential customers. This can lead to increased engagement, higher click-through rates, and ultimately more sales. However, implementing and monitoring measures for competitive separation can also help you to protect your brand.
In the realm of display advertising, competitive separation holds significant importance, influencing both programmatic buying and direct ad space purchases and is implemented at the impression level. This means that every time a user visits a publisher’s website, only ads from a particular advertiser are presented, while ads from competitors are deliberately excluded.
While competitive separation remains an option for advertisers, its application can vary widely among buyers and sellers. Some publishers may offer it as an additional service, often at a higher cost for premium inventory or with specific minimum spending thresholds. This applies equally to both programmatic and direct buying approaches and is primarily implemented using a list of their competitors’ names and web domains. For some brands, IAB content categories can be used to implement brand protection through competitive separation.
Direct buying
Direct buying involves purchasing ad inventory directly from publishers, bypassing automated bidding systems. Advertisers directly negotiate terms, such as ad placement, duration, and targeting criteria, with the publisher. In this scenario, competitive separation becomes a critical negotiation point. Advertisers may request exclusivity within specific ad spaces or insist on clauses ensuring that their ads are not displayed alongside those of direct competitors.
This dynamic can significantly impact pricing and availability. Publishers may charge higher rates for exclusive ad placements or limit competitive separation options to premium inventory and clients. Additionally, advertisers must carefully consider the implications of competitive separation on their campaign effectiveness and brand positioning.
In the context of direct ad space buying, competitive separation obligations are explicitly outlined in contracts or agreements between advertisers and publishers. Advertisers may stipulate specific requirements regarding the placement of their ads to mitigate the risk of brand dilution or confusion among consumers.
Programmatic buying
Programmatic buying involves automated processes where ad inventory is bought and sold in real-time auctions. Advertisers use sophisticated algorithms to bid on ad placements based on various parameters such as audience demographics, ad relevance, and bidding strategies. While this approach offers unparalleled efficiency and scalability, it also poses unique challenges for competitive separation.
Unlike direct ad space purchases, where advertisers negotiate terms directly with publishers, programmatic buying operates within an open marketplace where multiple advertisers compete for ad space simultaneously. This complexity introduces several factors that influence competitive separation:
Ad Placement: Programmatic platforms often prioritize ad placements based on bidding strategies and algorithmic optimizations. As a result, advertisers may find their ads displayed alongside those of direct competitors, potentially diluting their brand messaging and impacting campaign effectiveness.
Targeting Overlap: Programmatic algorithms optimize ad placements to reach specific audience segments. However, this targeting may inadvertently result in ads from competing brands being served to the same audience, leading to audience confusion and diminished impact.
Real-time Dynamics: Programmatic buying operates in real-time, with ad placements determined instantaneously based on bidding outcomes. This rapid pace makes it challenging to enforce strict competitive separation rules, as ads are served dynamically based on the prevailing market conditions
The effect of privacy-preserving initiatives on the display advertising ecosystems and competitive separation.
Recently passed privacy protection laws will alter the display advertising market. In particular, abandoning the use of third-party cookies will have a significant impact on advertising technologies and the ecosystem, as well as affect brand safety measures and competitive separation. IAB has already published a report criticizing Google’s Privacy Sandbox, which is intended to provide a privacy-aware solution for audience targeting. The report points out that the current version of the Privacy Sandbox does not support competitive separation for programmatic display advertising. You can find more about the Privacy Sandbox in our previous post on the topic.
Overall, whether through programmatic buying or direct ad space purchases, competitive separation remains a critical consideration in display advertising. Advertisers must navigate this landscape strategically and implement measures to optimize campaign performance while safeguarding brand integrity in a competitive marketplace. Although Google again postponed the aforementioned phasing out of third-party cookies from Chrome, one should still validate and monitor current measures for competitive separation.
New competitive separation feature in AdBubble
In such a fluid environment, we are happy to announce a new platform feature. In addition to the traffic and expenses analysis dashboards, we now provide the competitor separation dashboard to help advertisers and brand managers measure and validate competitive separation for their display ad campaigns and ensure brand safety.
Our system monitors display ad campaigns served on news websites across various locations. The collected data allows us to count how often display ads of a given advertiser or brand co-occur with ads from other advertisers when a user visits a web page. Based on this data, we provide a table with the top co-occurring advertiser, containing the total co-occurring frequency and ad volume and the difference in the ad volume for the two advertisers. We also provide a score indicating how similar two advertisers are based on their display ads and website descriptions.
Heatmap visualizing the co-occurring frequency by publisher
This intuitive visualization helps you quickly quantify the co-occurrence between your and your competitors’ ads on different websites, offering valuable insights that can help redirect or reinforce your ad strategies or negotiate with publishers if competitive separation criteria are not fulfilled.
Heatmap visualization of the co-occurring frequency by ad format
You can better understand your competitors strategies with our second heatmap that details how often you coopercred with competitors using the same ad format.. By seeing which formats are most co-occurring, you can optimize your ad format choices to stand out from the competition.
Finally, as always, you can download your competitive separation report and get it emailed to you on a regular basis or if a certain co-occurrence level is reached.
To wrap it up
Overall, the lack of brand protection in display advertising can have far-reaching consequences, including damage to brand reputation, decreased consumer trust, and diminished campaign performance. Implementing robust brand protection measures is essential to safeguard your brand’s integrity and maximize advertising effectiveness. Ensuring competitive separation across both direct buy and programmatic can be challenging. With AdBubble, you can now monitor and benchmark competitive separation for your display advertising campaigns and protect your brand. If your ad campaigns are not running on a website we monitor, you can contact us to ensure your brand is protected with competitive separation monitoring tailored to your needs.
Would you like to try out our Competitive Separation Dashboard? Are you interested in defining your customized ad campaign monitoring strategy?
Our cloud-based infrastructure is highly scalable and enables customized ad campaign monitoring at all levels, e.g., profiles, websites, locations, etc.
Get in touch
